Developer Due Diligence Checklist: How to Vet a GC for Multifamily

Why the GC Decision Is the Highest-Stakes Hire on a Multifamily Project

Choosing a general contractor for a multifamily project is one of the most consequential decisions a developer makes — and also one of the least standardized. Unlike lender selection or site acquisition, there’s no third party verifying a GC’s claims or forcing a review process. The vetting is entirely on the developer. That means a developer who skips steps or rushes the selection because a GC came in with the lowest bid is taking on real risk: cost overruns, schedule failure, subcontractor defaults, or a project that stalls mid-construction. Inabnet is a multifamily general contractor in San Diego that works with developers across the full project cycle, and this checklist reflects what rigorous GC vetting actually looks like in practice.

Step 1: Verify Licensing, Bonding, and Insurance — Before Everything Else

This is the non-negotiable baseline. A GC should be licensed in the state where the project is located, bonded with a surety bond, and insured with general liability coverage. Working with an unlicensed contractor creates real legal exposure — you typically cannot get insurance or pursue certain legal claims against an unlicensed contractor, according to Multifamily Loans. This isn’t a formality — it’s table stakes for anyone handling hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars of your capital.

A surety bond is especially important for multifamily projects financed with a construction loan, because most construction lenders require the GC to be bonded before they’ll fund the project. If a GC abandons the project or can’t complete it due to financial problems, the surety company either provides the cash to continue or replaces the contractor. The two key bonds on a multifamily project are the performance bond (guarantees project completion) and the payment bond (ensures subcontractors and suppliers get paid). Verify both. Also confirm the GC’s general liability policy covers subcontractor injury claims, which are one of the most common sources of construction litigation.

Step 2: Evaluate Multifamily-Specific Experience — Not Just Total Volume

A GC with $50 million in completed commercial work and no multifamily projects is not a qualified multifamily GC. Multifamily construction has specific technical requirements — unit-count scheduling, structured parking, podium construction, MEP coordination across hundreds of units, fire separation assemblies — that differ substantially from office, retail, or single-family work. Ask directly: how many multifamily projects have they completed in the past five years? What was the unit count and total construction value on each? Do they have active multifamily projects you can visit?

Portfolio review should go beyond photos. Ask to see project schedules and whether they hit the original completion date, and review any documented change order history. A strong multifamily contractor will be comfortable providing this level of detail. A GC that avoids specifics on past project outcomes during the vetting process is signaling a problem.

Step 3: Run the Reference Check — And Go Beyond the Provided List

References are standard, but most developers only call the three names a contractor hands them — which are, by definition, the contractor’s best relationships. The more valuable information is in the calls you make outside that list. Industry guidance from Multifamily Loans recommends contacting past clients not provided as references, or even past employees, to get a full picture of the firm’s reputation.

When you call references, ask specific questions: How quickly did the GC return calls? Did the project finish on schedule, and if not, by how many weeks? Were change orders handled transparently? Would they hire this GC again on a similar project? Those last two questions tend to generate the most useful information. A pattern of slow communication or disputed change orders across multiple references is a red flag that will compound across the 18 to 24 months of a multifamily build.

Step 4: Assess Financial Stability Before You Sign Anything

A GC can look credible and still be in financial trouble. Undercapitalized contractors are one of the primary causes of mid-project failures — they run short on cash, slow-pay subs, lose their subcontractor relationships, and projects stall. The basic financial check: request current financial statements and confirm the GC has a net worth at or above the project cost, plus enough liquidity to carry the project between draw disbursements. Verify the GC’s bonding capacity — the maximum project value a surety company will bond them for is a direct proxy for financial strength and track record.

If the GC is unwilling to share financial statements, that’s a significant red flag. A qualified contractor on a project in the $5 million to $30 million range should have no hesitation producing basic financials as part of a competitive bid process. Also check for any contractor license board actions, judgments, or liens in public records — your state’s contractor licensing board maintains these online.

Step 5: Spot Red Flags Early in the Bid Process

Several behaviors during the bidding phase predict problems during construction. A GC that comes in significantly below competing bids — more than 10 to 15% below the next lowest bidder — is often carrying unresolved assumptions that will show up as change orders later. Other warning signs include: unwillingness to pull permits, requesting cash-only payment, pressure to sign quickly before other bids are in, vague or inconsistent answers about subcontractor relationships, and no verifiable portfolio of completed multifamily projects.

It’s also worth understanding the most common mistakes developers make when hiring a GC for multifamily projects — several of them happen during the bid phase, before any contract is signed. Getting 3 bids minimum on smaller projects and 5 to 6 bids on larger ones creates enough price signal to identify outliers on either end.

Step 6: Align on Contract Structure and Communication Before You Commit

The contract is where the business relationship gets formalized, and the structure matters. The choice between GMP, lump sum, and cost-plus contract structures has real implications for how cost certainty and transparency are allocated between developer and GC. Review the contract specifically for: project start and completion dates, the payment schedule tied to milestone completions, how change orders are defined and approved, which party is responsible for permits, and what happens if the GC fails to perform. An experienced real estate attorney should review the contract before signing — this is not a step to skip on a multifamily development.

Communication style alignment also matters. Multifamily construction involves dozens of decisions per week, and a GC whose communication pace doesn’t match your expectations will create friction across the entire build. Clarify upfront: how often will you receive written schedule updates? Who is your single point of contact? What is the process when a subcontractor falls behind? Pre-construction consulting with the right firm can clarify these expectations before any commitment is made. Check the Inabnet FAQ for common developer questions about GC relationships on ground-up projects.

Frequently Asked Questions: Vetting a GC for Multifamily

How many bids should I get before choosing a GC for a multifamily project?

At minimum three bids for smaller projects, and five to six for larger ground-up developments. More bids create better price signal and give you a basis for comparison on schedule assumptions and subcontractor approaches. Don’t select based on price alone — the lowest bid is frequently the most expensive project when change orders are counted.

What should I look for in a GC’s references?

Call references the GC didn’t provide — contact information for past clients and former employees is findable through public project records and LinkedIn. Ask specifically about change order transparency, schedule performance, and communication responsiveness. A contractor with excellent reviews only from the references they curated tells you less than one reference call outside the approved list.

Does my lender care which GC I hire?

Yes. Most construction lenders require the GC to be approved before funding begins, and many lenders have minimum requirements around surety bond capacity, financial statements, and project experience. In some cases, the lender offering the permanent financing (takeout commitment) will also have approval rights on the GC. Consult with your construction lender early in the GC selection process.

What are the biggest red flags when vetting a GC?

Reluctance to provide references, inability or unwillingness to share financial statements, a bid that comes in dramatically below market without explanation, cash-only payment requirements, and no verifiable history of completed multifamily projects are the most consistent warning signs. A GC unwilling to pull permits is a non-starter — permit refusal creates legal liability for the developer.

Starting the GC Selection Process for Your Multifamily Project?

Inabnet works with developers in San Diego who are in the GC vetting and pre-construction phase — before a dollar of hard costs is spent. Start with a project consultation to understand what Inabnet brings to your specific site and program.

Contact Inabnet’s team or call us at (833) 390-4602.

Sources